and i fell in love with you (when i gave you up)
Mariko doesn’t really know how it happened; it wasn’t really like she was looking to get her heart broken or anything. She wasn’t even really looking for a boyfriend. Except Shuuji was always there, and Shuuji was always helpful, and Shuuji always smiled in his sympathetic, sunny way. And even when he didn’t mean it, even when he was lying, Shuuji always said “Yes.” Mariko had never met a boy like Shuuji before, but she thinks no one had really met anyone like Shuuji before. Shuuji wasn’t the smartest or the funniest or the most athletic; he wasn’t the class president and he wasn’t going to be valedictorian. But everyone liked Shuuji, everyone was a little bit in love with Shuuji, and maybe that meant more. (But, she learns, maybe that means nothing.)
Anyway, Shuuji was popular, and Mariko was popular, and they were the Golden Couple, they were what Love was supposed to be all about, they were a fairytale, except Mariko never got her Happily-ever-After. Shuuji wasn’t a prince, and Shuuji wasn’t in love with her, and their first, their last, their only date had been more of a good-bye than anything. “I–” said Shuuji, awkward and clumsy in his honesty, “I never meant–”
(But Shuuji hadn’t meant a lot of things.)
Mariko’s not exactly bitter. She’s sad and hurt, and probably she’s still in love with Shuuji, because it’s hard, even now, not to be in love with Shuuji. But she’s not bitter. She doesn’t blame Shuuji, because he may have lied, but she had been blind, and in the end–in the end, Shuuji had done the most selfless thing anyone’s ever done for Mariko. Shuuji had said “No,” because he didn’t want her to wait for him; because he wanted her to have a chance at happiness. The knowledge of that, Mariko holds on to, and tucks it away, warm and golden, in her heart.
Nobuko writes letters to Shuuji these days, quaint and rambling letters. Mariko helps. “Ask him if he’s drinking orange juice,” she says, as the two girls sit in an empty classroom after school, their dark heads bent over the same desk, late afternoon sunshine streaming in through the half-open windows. Nobuko’s pencil makes tap-tap noises on the desktop. “It’s cold season,” Mariko continues, “Tell him to be careful.”
“Aa,” agrees Nobuko. “And Akira too, to be careful.”
Shuuji writes back, short but frequent letters–his handwriting is neat and tidy and careful, and he never says much. But on the bottom of the page, where there is white, unused space, someone has scrawled crayon drawings of pigs and oceans and a happy, yellow sun. Akira is being stupid, of course, Shuuji usually concludes, but Mariko thinks he sounds happy. The crabs here are HUGE! he exclaims and It’s the middle of February and Akira wants to go surfing. He won’t believe me when I tell him that he’s crazy. ‘Akira crazy?’ he says, and laughs in that stupid nasal giggle. Idiot. but that’s just Shuuji showing his affection. It’s not what Mariko had expected of the Old Shuuji, but she’s beginning to learn that maybe Old Shuuji hadn’t really been True Shuuji, and she thinks maybe she never really knew Shuuji anyway.
“So it wasn’t even really love, was it?” she smiles at Nobuko, who looks vaguely anxious and vaguely sympathetic. “I’m all right. I’m not heart-broken over Shuuji-kun. You can stop looking worried and you can tell him to stop feeling guilty.”
It’s a small lie. She’s not heart-broken over Shuuji, but she’s not really over Shuuji. And it’s just as easy, just as simple, just as natural to fall in love with him through his letters–his truer self, bare and stark, not so polished and not so smooth as the mask that Shuuji tried to present to the world, but just as brave and just as kind. Shuuji is Shuuji is Shuuji is Shuuji, thinks Mariko.
She doesn’t tell him this. It’s all right to be a little bit in love with Shuuji (everyone is a little bit in love with Shuuji), but she doesn’t think she really wants to do anything about it. Not just yet. She thinks he needs to find himself first, however cliche and stupid that sounds; and there had been his “no,” his sincere wish for her happiness, for her not to wait.
“Tell him,” she adds, as Nobuko writes the final few sentences. “Tell him that we’re all fine here. Tell him that we’re–we’re happy.”
–
Two days before he’d left, Mariko found Shuuji sitting alone on top of the playground jungle behind the school. She bit her lips and thought about it for a moment, then climbed up to sit beside him. “Hey,” she said, and bumped shoulders with him. “Shuuji-kun.”
His eyes flickered towards her, and there was something at once wistful and tentative in his smile. “Oh, hello,” he said, but it sounded stilted.
She understood, sighed, rolled her eyes. “I’m not angry with you,” she told him. “And–y’know. Thank you, for the other day.”
He half-laughed, half-huffed, and it was a derisive exhalation. “I should be apologizing–”
“No,” said Mariko. “No, don’t. It–It was good.”
He didn’t say anything in reply, so they sat in silence for a while, looking up at the grey December sky. Eventually, Shuuji said, “I’m sorry,” anyway. “I don’t have any right to love you,” he added, soft and quiet. There was a distant look in his eyes, but he was smiling a little. It was a sad smile, half-wistful. “Boys who make girls cry have no right to love them.” He looked at her again from the corner of his eyes, and repeated, “I’m sorry.”
“Well,” said Mariko. “It’s all right. I had fun, you know. Even with how everything turned out. I really did have fun.”
“I’ll have to take you to the beach for real sometime, then,” Shuuji laughed, “if that’s your idea of a fun date. You know that it was just Nobuta and Akira tipping sand over the PA?”
“You have good friends,” said Mariko, and bit her lip when the smile faded from Shuuji’s face.
“Yeah,” he said, almost a whisper. “I have good friends.”
It started to snow.
Suddenly, Shuuji turned to her, serious and earnest. “Mariko,” he said. “Mariko, don’t wait for me, all right? Don’t wait for me.”
“I–”
“Promise,” said Shuuji. He tugged on one of her hands, and laced pinkies with her. “Promise you won’t wait for me, and you’ll find someone better, and — promise me you’ll be happy. Okay?”
Mariko stared at him for a long moment. She crooked her pinky in his. “Okay,” she said. “Okay. I promise. I’ll be happy.”
I’ll be happy.
–
In the end, maybe she gave him up, or maybe he gave her up, or maybe neither one of them gave up. Maybe it doesn’t matter either way. Maybe she’s still a little in love with him, and maybe he’s still learning about truth and honesty; but all he’s ever wanted, really, was her happiness, and she thinks that’s the greatest thing you can want for someone.
She’s happy.